Stillwater Tragedy: Two Killed, One Injured in Shooting; Suspect Theodore McCloud Arrested in Double Homicide
STILLWATER, OK — A community is left shaken after a horrific act of violence unfolded in Stillwater, Oklahoma, where two people were killed and another injured in a shooting that has since led to an arrest. Authorities say the incident occurred on the evening of Monday, July 28, 2025, and has now been classified as a double homicide.
The victims have been identified as:
-
Vanessa Henry, 38, of Stillwater – deceased at the scene
-
Andrew Rice, 35, of Stillwater – deceased at the scene
-
Carman Murphy, 34, also of Stillwater – survived with at least one gunshot wound and was transported to a hospital, where she is reportedly in stable condition
💥 The Shooting and Initial Response
The Stillwater Police Department received reports of a shooting just after 8:00 p.m., prompting officers to respond swiftly to the scene. Upon arrival, they discovered a harrowing scene: two adults fatally wounded and one more critically injured. First responders immediately began lifesaving measures on Carman Murphy, who was quickly transported to a local hospital.
Officials confirmed that Vanessa Henry and Andrew Rice were pronounced dead at the scene due to gunshot wounds. Their deaths have been ruled as homicides by the Payne County Coroner’s Office.
🔍 Suspect Identified and Arrest Made
The suspect was identified as Theodore DeMarrio McCloud, 36, of Langston, Oklahoma. According to investigators, McCloud fled the scene prior to law enforcement’s arrival, prompting a regional manhunt. Working in coordination with nearby jurisdictions and utilizing witness statements, surveillance footage, and tips from the public, authorities were able to track down McCloud.
Within 24 hours, Stillwater Police confirmed that Theodore McCloud had been apprehended without incident and is now in custody. He is currently being held at the Payne County Detention Center, facing preliminary charges that include two counts of first-degree murder and one count of attempted murder. Formal charges are expected to be filed by the Payne County District Attorney in the coming days.
⚖️ Investigation Details and Motive
While the motive remains under investigation, early indications suggest that the shooting may have stemmed from a personal dispute or an escalation of a domestic altercation. Authorities have not released information on the relationship between McCloud and the victims but noted that all parties were known to each other.
Detectives from the Stillwater Police Department’s Criminal Investigations Division, alongside the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation (OSBI), are actively working the case. Search warrants have been executed, and forensic evidence is being processed to solidify the timeline of events.
💬 Community Impact and Response
The violent nature of this crime has sent shockwaves throughout the Stillwater community. Friends and neighbors have begun to gather to mourn the lives lost and express concern for Carman Murphy’s recovery. Local pastors and mental health advocates have offered grief counseling and support services to families and residents affected by the tragedy.
Stillwater Police Chief expressed his condolences to the families of the victims, stating:
“This senseless act of violence has taken two cherished lives and left another fighting to heal. Our thoughts are with the victims’ families, and we remain committed to seeking justice on their behalf.”
📌 Summary of Key Facts
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Victims | Vanessa Henry (38), Andrew Rice (35) – deceased; Carman Murphy (34) – injured |
| Suspect | Theodore DeMarrio McCloud (36), Langston |
| Date of Incident | Monday, July 28, 2025 |
| Location | Stillwater, Oklahoma |
| Charges | 2× First-Degree Murder, 1× Attempted Murder |
| Current Status | Suspect in custody at Payne County Jail |
| Investigation Ongoing by | Stillwater PD & Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation |
🙏 In Remembrance
Vanessa Henry and Andrew Rice are being remembered by loved ones for their warmth, compassion, and community spirit. Friends describe Vanessa as a vibrant and resilient woman who worked tirelessly to provide for her family. Andrew, a father and aspiring small business owner, was known for his generosity and strong work ethic. A memorial vigil is being planned by local residents and will be announced in the coming days.
📞 Public Assistance
Anyone with additional information about the shooting is encouraged to contact the Stillwater Police Department or submit anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers.